
Records are kept by the secretary of the district of that particular lodge, I don't know where they keep all past records, but they would be like a register and people would only be listed as attending monthly meetings.
There are some records for the Orange Lodge at Liverpool Records Office.
I think your best bet would be to contact Liverpool Provincial Club at Everton Road. But I don't think you will have any luck, the information is confidential. The photo is wonderful, that would go down well at "The Provvy" As you have the district numbers on the colaretts, that might be a great asset to have and maybe someone will know what district they were from.
I could do some asking for you, nearly all my family were in the lodge.
The best of luck
Jan