Yes, it's fun, though I have to read it aloud to work out what it is saying, and even then don't get some of it.
The only Taylor I have is Benjamin, probably one of the deacons, or at least important enough to be in an official group photo of the chapel dignitaries. He could be the same Benjamin who died in 1915 aged 56, husband of Elizabeth Margaret, mentioned in the Rochdale Cemetery list on Interment.com, but I'm only guessing there.
Re Butterworth Taylor: I suppose he was given his mother's maiden name or that of some relative. Butterworth as a surname is a real Rochdale name, and there are a huge number of them. I have some in my family, but tracing them is a nightmare, because they seem to share so few first names. There is another chapel member called Simeon Butterworth, a local councillor, and there was also an area of Rochdale called Butterworth.
If you think Benjamin is one of yours, I can let you have a copy of his photo. Just send me your email address in a PM. Sorry I can't help with the Barnicoats, Howarths and Grindrods.
Gill