Tom,
It is possible that John and Gavin were born in the USA, especially as John was in the war in Boston, MA. I will see if I can contact the David Ross who wrote the book. I did write to a Don Ross in WI, who was also quoted. It will take a bit before he gets back to me, but I will have more info I am sure when he does. The History of Cape Negro and Blanche, 3rd edition 1991. Perhaps he has more info in it. I will see if I can locate any passenger records that will show Thomas Alexander Lyle coming over from Scotland. Now to figure out when he might have come over!
The problem is that I went onto the LDS site and found John and Gavin Lyle, sons to Thomas Alexander Lyle from Scotland. Perhaps this was a link that shouldn't have been made on my part, but I was also going on the info from the Ross book just mentioned.
IF John Lyle was born around 1785, and I say this since his first child (Sarah, I think) was born in 1808, which would make him 25....and IF Thomas (if that is his dad) was about 25 when he had him, that would place him to be born around 1760. Maybe.
So....an educated guess might make Thomas coming over to Boston (?) between perhaps 1780-1785.
Of course a twist on this might be that the Lyles did indeed originally settle in Nova Scotia, but John went off to fight in the war.....educated guesses, but still just guesses.
Again, I appreciate the help. Stick with me if you can. I'll figure this out soon enough! I have also done my maternal line of the Slaters and have gotten as far back as 1826. Got stuck with no info on my g.g.g.g.g.grandfather Thomas Slater from Muff Parish, Drumskellan, Donegal, Ireland.
Yes, MORE darn Thomases! I am beginning to really hate that name! I have also done the Tompkins line on my great grandfather's side. I have been able to go back as 1275 on that with help from folks who have written a book or two on the Tompkins family.
Cheers,
Joy