Dee-jay, that “date of birth” for Thomas was probably a mistranscription for “date of baptism”.
I have been corresponding with Ian, and he has found a possible alternate baptism for James Gill, son of John and Isabella, at St Sidwell, Exeter, in Oct 1810! Have you seen it and ruled it out?
I emailed you a couple of days ago about our DNA project, but the email bounced. Could you try emailing me, please?
jeanffrench
Responses:
(1) I had already reached that conclusion.

(2) I discounted the John/Isabella suggestion many moons ago, after finding all the links with Yarcombe and
Defiance coaching activities plus the Uncle James CRABB of Northleigh mentioned in the 1818 Settlement Examination taken at Yarcombe of young James GILL, and Churchstanton employment with Robert OSBORNE until he went out of business. More recently I found a likely baptism - 20 Apr 1834 at Axminster - son of James GILL,
Post Boy, & Elizabeth for the James GILL aged 7 months buried 14 Sep 1834 at Colyton - Elizabeth's birthplace. The only missing link is a Settlement Examination for Elizabeth GILL after James' untimely death in 1844.
According to Hanson a common route for progression from saddle to coach bench was stable boy/horse-keeper/post boy/coachman.
(3) I'll PM my current email address.
dee-jay
P.S. I joined Devon FHS this year for the purpose of seeing all their parish register images.

.