Hi Trish,
Thanks so much for your efforts and your response was not unexpected. Yes, family lore states we are from the highlands and from Clan Glencoe. Another family member provided the following.
“Alexander McDonald is, by way of family legend, the grandson of the McDonald Clan of Glencoe chiefton, Alexander. There is disparity however over which of this Alexander's two sons, Alexander 2 or John, fathered Alexander McDonald. Some sources site Alexander 2 as the father, while others site his brother John. Both brothers were present and participated in the defense of the infamous Glencoe Massacre (1690).” Our records suggest Alexr was born about 1710-1715.
I felt it might be easier to trace family from Ellon based on information given as fact. However, what is known is Alexr married Isabella (Isobel) Mclaughlin, December 12, 1720, Old Parrish, Greenock, Renfrewshire. Then the question becomes why would the family leave the clan and travel from Greenock to Ellon? That’s a long way on foot! Perhaps I should focus my attention in Renfrewshire.
Based on the above, the John you so kindly uncovered could not be the son due to mother (Janet). By the way, it is John A. MacDonald (McDonald). Also, Isabella died in America. And, as you point out, the John McDonald having children at the same time could very well have been Alexr’s brother.
Another source provided “Macdonald, Alexander of Aberdeen (Male) Date: 1744 Occupation(s): merchant, commerce(s) Subscribed to The ancient Liturgy of the Church of Jerusalem, 1744, RATTRAY, Thomas. London, Subject: religion”
So, we have Alexr in Ellon and/or Aberdeen, leaves wife and 4 children, supposedly participates in the battle of Culloden, comes back to Aberdeen and purchases land in 1746. Then the question is why and how could he do this knowing he is being hunted for his activity at Culloden? Gets caught, is moved from Aberdeen to Liverpool for transportation on the Gildart, and sent to America. Are there any records that would substantiate his capture and transportation from Aberdeen?
I’m not confused at all. One would think uncovering facts would be simple. It’s only been 260 years (grin).
Trish, thanks again and any further help or guidance will be greatly appreciated.
Regards,
Jim McDonald