Hi
Thank you for all the extra information. My geography isn't brilliant when it comes to Rutland/Leicestershire, the boundaries seem to keep changing sometimes the Arnsby family live in Oakham Rutland, sometimes Oakham Leicestershire so there is a good chance the William you mentioned could be the right one.
JOHN ARNSBY born/bapt 12 Sept 1757 Oakham Rutland to John Arnsby & Mary Palmer, showing as John Armsby in Register. John married twice, to Mary Tinson and Elizabeth Brewster
MARY TINSON 1753 Melton Mowbray Leics to Will Tinson & Elizabeth Henfrey bapt 17 May 1753. John married Mary (spinster) 14 Feb 1785 Oakham Leics by banns, they had 4 children born Oakham and baptised at the Baptist church Elizabeth bapt 29 Dec 1785. Catherine bapt 22 Sept-22 Oct 1787 Rhoda born 3 Mar 1789 married John Watchorn (Mary and John are my ancestors) Phebe bapt 13 Mar 1790. Husband Benjamin Vernor born c1790 married Oakham Leics 29 Jun 1816 Children Arnsby 1816 Robert 1817 John 1818 William 1820 James 1825 Mart 1827 Mary 1829 Elizabeth 1831
Elizabeth Brewster (Julie's 5x-Gt-Grandfather's Wife) c1760 Oakham Leics. John Arnsby (bachelor) married Elizabeth Brewster (spinster) banns on 7 May 1780 Oakham Leics.
Regards
Julie