Hi Rosie,
I've just been reading your post, I think the 'favourite city' got me!

Although I'm not related in any way, I thought I'd be 'ard-faced' and follow your clues! I hope you don't mind.

I know you've got a lot, if not all of this info but just in case, here goes...
1871 Census/LancsBMDEdwin Worthington b1848 hairdresser employing one apprentice, living at 25 Lodge Lane, Toxteth Park.
Mary Bennett (Wife) b1848. Married 1868 St George, Everton
Sarah A. Worthington (daughter) b1870
Is this his dad?
From the
1851 Census.
Richard Worthington b1811 Occ. Baker
Sarah (Wife) b1812
Martha (daughter) b1832
Cordelia (daughter) b1836
Richard J. (Son) 1837
Mary E. (daughter) b1839
Thomas (Son) b1841
Edwin (Son) b1848
Virginia? (daughter) b1850
Address in 1851: Marlborough St. 1 Court
(They moved about from census to census but seemed to remain in the Scotland Road area.)
Hope I'm not barking up the wrong 'tree', so to speak.
By the way, West Derby registration district extended to Warrington and beyond in those days!!
Here's some sites you may find useful :
http://www.toxteth.net/http://www.lancashirebmd.org.uk/marriages.htmlhttp://www.streetmap.co.ukIf I can be of help, just give a shout! Bye for now,
feralcat 