Mary,
Just getting ready for week end in Manchester... Sunderland are playing Millwall in FA Cup semi-final...
But in the meantime.... although I have a good hunch he was born in Seaton Sluice... as C1881 says. Whereas the reference to Earsdon is not a 'birthplace' but the 'ancient parish whose boundaries he was born in.
And Earsdon parish covered a big area, including Seaton Sluice, Old Hartley, New Hartley, Seaton Delaval, Seghill, Buuradon, Holywell etc...
My g/father was born in New Hartley.. but census records show him as b. Earsdon, birth registration records show Tynemouth .
I was born in Bebside Colliery village, but officials would have put me down as 'born Horton' which was our equivalent 'ancient parish'
Other examples are Wallsend-born people put down as 'born Longbenton.
And down in Co Durham , Seaham Harbour counted as ' Dalton-le-Dale..... stop me !!!!
Anyway, that's my hunch for your Robert.
But one thing I am sure of.... C1851 has he and his family as living in 'Sandy Island' and not Seaton Delaval !!
Sandy Island ( isn't an island) is the bit of land on the north bank ( Blyth side ) of the river/stream/burn Seaton. Near where the pub the Melton Constable is/was.
To read background/see maps/see photos of this area
go to
communities.northumberland.gov.ukno'www' required.
Enter site, click on 'Seaton Sluice' and browse at leisure.
Another angle with your gang... that 69 yr old Elizabeth Broderick, widow of a sailor, on C1851... I think she is a contender 10 yr old Robert's grannie !
Next time I visit Northumberland County Records Office at Morpeth, I shall look up Earsdon parish records, for Robert's birth etc... was the family Church of England ?
Good Hunting
Michael @ Cowpen