Hello, cousin Lesley!
I can't help but wonder what life was like back then - can't have been very good for them...you will have noticed from this thread that Patons were bailing out of Auchtergaven at a tremendous rate.
Have you any information on the line further back than Andrew and Ann? I am about to take another run at it. Save me some work, please!

My daughter was in Scotland a couple of years back, and as her trip north was through the right area, I asked if she would pop into Bankfoot Cemetery and see if she could find any Paton gravestones. She later told me that it was an absolutely surreal experience. We live a 'modern' life, far away from most of our relations and this is all she knows. She found the experience of going into a cemetery where it seemed like every other person was a relation of hers, quite overwhelming. She did not have enough time or daylight to film all of the Paton markers. And there would also have been family buried in other cemeteries nearby. I hope to get up there, maybe next year.
I didn't know that Andrew and Ann's wills were on Scotland's People. I am an ancestry member and have been deluding myself for several years now that they are 'just about' to reach an agreement. Amazing. I'm only married to a Scot and have become cheap by association.
If you have any info on Andrew's ancestors, I would appreciate it, and if I have anything you need, you are welcome to it. I can't remember if it's covered in this thread, but I have 5 children that look like sibs to your Andrew:
Andrew & Ann PATON
James 29 Jul 1794
twins (?) Janet and William 11 Dec 1796
Andrew 12 Jan 1800
Peter 3 Jun 1803
John 9 Jul 1809
There is a record of a 'female' PATTON named Janet William , father Andrew PATTON in Auchtergaven. The timing is right, and I haven't been able to see the fiches for myself to confirm that it is a daughter or twins. I include it because the pronunciation of the surname is right as is the time and place. Who knows. At some point I will get over there and get into the records and bankrupt myself.

If I find anything else, I'll post it.
Cheers,
Holly