Hi John
You're right! I checked back through the censuses and found a Puxted from Ewhurst.
Indexed as Buxton
1841 HO107/1109/10/41/5
Shoreham, Ewhurst, SussexIsaac Bovis, 45, Ag Lab, yes
Mary Bovis, 45, yes
William Buxted, 30, Ag Lab, yes
(further down same page)
Prawls, EwhurstHenry Burgess, 30, farmer, yes
Elizabeth Burgess, 25, yes
Ann Burgess, 5, yes
Charles Gouch? 15, Male Serv, yes
William Bovis, 20, M.S. yes
Sarah Sanders, 20, F.S. yes
Indexed as Perxted.
1851 HO107/1636/221/13
Shoreham, Ewhurst, SussexWilliam Puxted, head, 41, farmer 72 acres, 3 labourers, b. Ewhurst, Sussex
Mary, wife, 55, farmer's wife, b. Battle, Sussex
William, son in law, u, 33, Ag Lab, b. Battle, Sussex
Indexed as Pakted
1861 RG9/564/28/6
Brafaw? Ewhurst, SussexWilliam Puxted, head, 51, farmer 71 acres employing 1 boy, b. Ewhurst, Sussex
Mary Puxted, wife, 64, b. Battle, Sussex
William Bovis, son in law, un, 42, farmer in Co ? b. Battle, Sussex
Lydia S(inkspot)ter, serv, 11, house servant, b. Brightling, Sussex
1871 RG10/1035/33/16
Brapes/Brasses?, Ewhurst, SussexWilliam Puxted, head, 61, farm bailiff, b. Ewhurst, Sussex
Mary Puxted, wife, 74, domestic, b. Battle, Sussex
William Bovis, lodger, unmar, 53, Ag Lab, b. Battle, Sussex
Louisa Playford, servant, unmar, 18, general servant domestic, b. Worthiam? Sussex
Unfortunately I can't see a William Puxted on the IGI so don't know if/how he might fit into Mary's family.
I take it that Mary Puxted's mother was Eleanor Goodsell? There are quite a few Goodsells in Ewhurst on the 1841 census.

Koromo