Hi grigglespot
I'm not sure exactly what information you are searching for - you may like to give some information on same - but looking at your general information
There appear to be no births in NSW around the time given for a James Giltrap. In case you didn't know, you can search NSW online at
www.bdm.nsw.gov.au (follow the family history link)
There is the following birth record for 1891 with a slight change to the spelling
35461/1891 GILLTRAP JAMES Father GEORGE D Mother CLARA WAGGA WAGGA
George and Clara had 9 children (GILLTRAP) - most at Wagga (the first at Albury) - from 1881 to 1898 and one, George, registered as GILTRAP who died when only a few years old.
There is a marriage in 1880 for George and Clara (name now spelt with one L)
2369/1880 GILTRAP GEORGE D BARTHOLOMEW CLARA ALBURY
There is a marriage for James and Ethel in 1917
2203/1917 GILTRAP JAMES L O'CONNELL ETHEL I WAGGA WAGGA
so her name was Ethel O'Connell.
If the James in 1891 is not yours, could your James have been born in another state or overseas?
Trish