Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Mhillbilly

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 ... 11
1
Hi Andy

A final PS to this topic

I checked the 1871 census although not labelled as in that order it appears they are listed in regimental number order with Pte Golding before Rowland and Pte Clark after. Numbers match with Clark if Rowland is 2015 Clark is 2025 but 1 person is missing from between Rowland and Golding as he appears 7 not 8 places before Rowland.  To me that is as close as we can get.

Regards

Tony

2
Hi Andy and thanks again for all your effort on this

So based on the assumption that 4 years and 213 days is calculated up to 10 Apr 1876 and that anytime between his desertion and completion of sentence is not included in that calculation then enlistment would have been on 21 January 1871 (fits with your regimental number allocation sequence.)

How did I get that, my calculation would be 4 years and 213 days less 73 we know about post sentence serving so enlistment would be 4 years and 140 days (213-73) before 10 June desertion date.  This is 21 Jan 1871.  But for me late January 1871 is close enough.

Looking again at the pension record where 30 pound seems to be a common buy out amount and as you calculated Rowlands's deferred pay would be not cover it.  How Rowland came by that amount on 15 Apr 1876 will be another mystery maybe to return to later.

That closes the topic for me and thanks again for your help.

Tony

 

3
Thank you Andy j2022 for a thorough response

Yes you are correct my 2GG is Rowland White and he was born 20 Oct 1851 so I presume no child soldier calculation needed.

I had the pension calculation record but had not appreciated it did show a purchase to buy out.
I wonder how he came by that amount I assume that 30 pounds was deducted from final pay?

I am in New Zealand so visit to UK archives is not possible. 

As with most things in genealogical research we do go down rabbit holes at times and this was one of mine.  I actually cannot find my 2GG's death record and while searching for that have re focused on every event in his early life.  His last appearance was in the 1881 census in Manchester, and he has a few events post military service events in Manchester, so the military events needed to be re verified.  The area of Manchester was Hulme in which there was a cavalry barracks (12th Lancers stationed there)

The only two things left in the military events is to confirm his enlistment date and to verify the first forces war record Rowland is my Rowland.  These are related but need to be reconciled with the known census record that puts him in Aldershot sometime between 2 April and 30 April 1871.

My final question would be your best estimate of that enlistment date.
To reconcile the facts of the 1871 worldwide army index assuming both records relate to my Rowland and the census definitely does then the enlistment date needs to be early April 1871
(how long would a recruit be labelled a recruit until he became a private in the regiment?)

Thanks again for all your efforts.


4
I need help to understand how army service length is calculated and how a court martial sentence length would interact with date of discharge.

I have calculated length of time between known dates and cannot reconcile how the calculation is made.

My 2GG grandfather was in the 12th Lancers from at least 1871 to 1876

The known facts

1871 census appears as soldier. 12th Lancers, East cavalry barracks, Aldershot. Census date 2 April although form revised 30 April 1871

Forces war records 1871 worldwide army index. Started 1 April complete 30 June 1871.  Manchester recruiting depot district 7, Service number - unnumbered, location Manchester, rank recruit.

Forces war records 1871 worldwide army index. Started 1 April complete 30 June 1871.  12th (Prince of Wales Royal) Lancers, Regimental number 1215, location Aldershot, rank Private.

He was listed in the Police Gazette of 7 July 1875 as having deserted on 10 June 1875 when at Manchester, with 12th Lancers, Regimental number 1215.

Court martialed at Shorncliffe (Kent) on 9 December 1875 and was sentenced to 56 days hard labour for desertion.

On 15 April 1876 Pte. 1215 was discharged from 12th Lancers with a bad character following 4 years and 213 days service of which only 73 days counted towards pension.

Date calculations

56 days after 9 Dec 1875 is 3 Feb 1876

56 days before 15 April 1876 is 19 Feb 1876, or 129 days before 9 Dec 1875 

4 years and 213 days before 15 April 1876 is 15 Sep 1871
4 years and 213 days before 9 Dec 1875 is 10 May 1871
4 years and 213 days before 10 Jun 1875 is 9 Nov 1870

Questions
How does length of sentence reconcile with court martial and discharge date?
What would be normal for start of sentence after court martial and end of sentence and discharge?

When does length of service end - on desertion, or on discharge?

Because of the 1871 census, 2GG was in army in April 1871 that would seem to make service end on desertion?

What causes pensionable days to be so different from service days?

Thanks for any help on this. 

5
Thank you for that, obvious when someone else explains
It was the inconsistency of use that folled me
Thanks again


6
Handwriting Deciphering & Recognition / Unknown place on military history sheet
« on: Saturday 12 April 25 04:20 BST (UK)  »
Help please to decipher the unknown places on this extract from my grandfathers military history
 
According to the instructions on the form countries should be listed and home used for all the UK
Which if adhered means the unknowns are countries?

I can read Home, India, Unknown, Mesopotamia and something else?, unknown, Malta, Home, India

The unknowns are for shorter periods, as is Malta, if that helps. 7,25, & 22 days respectively.

Thanks

7
Free Photo Restoration & Date Old Photographs / Muzaffarnagar in India.
« on: Thursday 10 April 25 05:30 BST (UK)  »
Hi

A restoration please for the photos of my grandad in India in the 1920's
These are different from the 'postcard' type I have just uploaded as they appear to be actual photos, no postcard printing on back, and have discoloured and worn very differently to the other 'postcard'

Does anyone know why the difference in the use of media? 

Grandad was in the Duke of Cornwall's light infantry in India. The other post on the postcard had words that said it was Muzaffarnagar in India. but I am not sure if this is the same place.

No info on the back

Thanks

8
Hi

A restoration please for the photo of my grandad in India in the 1920's
This is the Duke of Cornwall's light infantry regimental police in camp on a march in Muzaffarnagar in India. The words on the back of the photo/postcard (unsent) which also names my grandfather as 3rd from left

Thanks

9
Thanks for the comments and I appreciate the need to treat any 'hints' based on other peoples genealogical research with caution

My question was about the level of the DNA match as with 4th great grandfather as MRCA 5th cousin is the most likely match

in this case I have researched my tree and am comfortable with the genealogical facts my question was on the DNA results

 Of course, the greater the cM the greater the certainty but what about 5th cousins matches at 22 and 20cM?

 

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 ... 11