I too have a few drownings in my ancestral tree, since my mother came from Banffshire and a fishing background. It would have been nice to have some account of writeups of missing boats/drownings to add to my tree. I have the Buckie site but it would help to look further for information.
Dear KHP
I'm not an expert on finding reports of drownings but the newspapers of the time are often a good bet. Those available on-line with particular relevance to Scotland include the Scotsman, Caledonian Mercury, Glasgow Herald, Aberdeen Journal, Dunfermline Journal. Many rootschatters, regardless of where they are based, will have access to these and I'm sure would be glad to help.
If you're asking for a look-up, please post as much detail as possible, names, dates, name of ship if known, starting point, destination, home town etc. All of these can be used as key words in a search. In this case, the detail given was not enough to find anything but, as I have followed several of these threads, I thought there was a good chance the source was the Fife FHS death CD. A search on that for "seaman" and 1849 revealed the men were from Pittenweem and that keyword picked up the reports. Incidentally, the CD also mentions that a report would be found in the Fife Journal on 8 March.
I hope this helps and you manage to find something on your family.
Regards
Helen