Pufflet - I am not related to this family, but I run a Wanless surname study, and at our site (
www.wanlessweb.org), we have the will of David Wanliss who made his will in 1830 and died in 1832 at Abernethy. His wife was Janet Moon, who pre-deceased him. In this will, he names "Andrew Barclay tenant of Balgonie" and "David Barclay, James Wanliss Barclay, and Catherine Barclay my grandchildren, being the children of the marriage of the said Andrew Barclay and my deceased daughter Elizabeth Wanliss", and later in the will, he adds the child Janet to the same list. FamilySearch or the OPR shows birth/baptism records for these 4 children at Abernethy (David 1819, Janet 1821, James Wanless Barclay 1823, Catherine Nicol Barclay 1825). Their mother Elizabeth Wanless must have died between Catherine's birth in Nov 1825 and the writing of David's will in Sep 1830. It looks to me like Andrew remarried (to Jean Ritchie? Is there a marriage record?) between 1825 and 1831 and they had Elizabeth and Georgina. Andrew, and presumably Jean, were dead by the 1841 census, and the older siblings David & Janet appear with their younger siblings Elizabeth & Georgina at the family farm at Balgonie. At least, that's how it looks to me.
I like the theory that Andrew Barclay was a son of David Barclay & Catherine Nicol. Andrew's wife Elizabeth was born in 1784; if Andrew was born to David & Catherine in 1788, he would have been just a few yrs younger than Elizabeth.
Question: Have you seen the marriage of Georgina Barclay & John Smith? Does it not name her parents?
regards,
Holly