Regarding Elizabeth Goldsmith's history...
Have you located a marriage with Wm Rayner, and death for William Rayner?.
Have you located a marriage with Robert Jones?
Is it possible that she was not married to either of these men?
The record of the marriage to William Rayner is not recorded from Norfolk Island or records lost but William Rayner registered both his marriages to the Quakers in Hobart and all his children in 1834.. I have the copy of those records..
Robert Jones marriage..it had to be a bigamist marriage by Elizabeth Goldsmith as she was still married to William Rayner, and he married Susan Chapman whilst still married to Elizabeth..
So how much did the marriages count from Norfolk Island if they failed...not much, I suppose they were forced on them as well as the women were sent there to be with the men.
But the relationship with Robert Jones lasted till his death and was recognised by the Police and gave her a pension etc..
but the dates I have are William Rayner 19 Sept 1791 as per the Friends record and 1797 for Robert Jones.
But all the children of Elizabeth Goldsmith were baptised on Norfolk Is. by Rev. H. Fulton the 20 May 1804 and all with the surname of Jones. ie William and George sons of William Rayner and Roberts daughters Elizabeth and Mary. The boys lived with them on Norfolk and in Sydney until the boys went to Hobart..with William Rayner Snr possibly in 1814 as per the public notices but the Williams get mixed up here..