RootsChat.Com

General => The Common Room => Topic started by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 03:52 BST (UK)

Title: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 03:52 BST (UK)
In the 1921 census i have listed two parents Mrs Smart (in her 60's) with two children a boy and a girl (aged in their 20's) both are shown as single, last name Smart. There is also a grand daughter listed (aged 6). GRO lists the child as Ida Hall Smart, mother's maiden name is blank.
I assume the child was probably illegitimate from one of the two children but not sure who.
How do i enter the child in ancestry.com? The only relationship i know for sure is to the grand parents.
Thank you
Rob
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: maddys52 on Thursday 06 April 23 04:14 BST (UK)
It would be quite unusual I would think for a child born to unmarried mother to be with her father, so I would suggest she is the child of the girl in her 20s. (Does the grandmother have any other children who are not with them in 1921 that could also be the parent of the 6 year old?) Do you know if the grandchild married - who does she name as father?
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 04:24 BST (UK)
maddys52,
Thank you for your reply.
There a no other siblings of the two shown in the census. As best i can tell the child (Ida Smart) ened up marrying an Eric Martin in 1935 in Staffordshire. I can't find a proper marriage certificate to verify her father.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: bbart on Thursday 06 April 23 04:35 BST (UK)
There are two older daughters on the 1901 census, if I am looking at the right folks!

Ida's birth reg will give the name of who is claiming to be the mother.... it is just blank on the GRO index to indicate an unmarried Smart is mom. Her first name should still be on it.

If you don't want to get her birth registration, as a work-around, make a new daughter for Mr. and Mrs. Smart, name her "one of the daughters" or something similar,  and attach Ida to her.   If you ever figure out which daughter is mom, you can move Ida to her, and delete the fake daughter.  At least this way, you get Ida attached.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: bbart on Thursday 06 April 23 04:46 BST (UK)
. As best i can tell the child (Ida Smart) ened up marrying an Eric Martin in 1935 in Staffordshire. I can't find a proper marriage certificate to verify her father.

You would have to order it from the GRO, but there is a very good chance that it will have no father's name on it.
The district/volume/page number you would need to order it can be found by looking up Ida on https://www.freebmd.org.uk/

Often, single moms would put a hint in the child's name, so if the name Hall isn't in the family, that might be where that comes from.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 06:31 BST (UK)
Thanks to all, I will at this stage make the assumption the child’s mother is the daughter listed and not the son.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: amondg on Thursday 06 April 23 06:42 BST (UK)
Parents  (1911 had 8 children 4 alive 4 deceased)
John Smart married Catherine Birks 12 October 1885

Children
Elizabeth 1885 reg Wolstanton  death 1888 age 2 Newcastle under Lyme

Maud Beatrice 1888 reg Newcastle under Lyme married Samuel Wilshaw 1909 (so not Ida's mother)

Martha Ellen 1889 reg Wolstanton married Wilmot Eardley 1920 (living away as a servant 1911 married age 31 possibly Ida's mother)

John William 1891 reg Wolstanton baptized 25 December 1891 buried 28 December 1891 aged 3 days

Elizabeth 1893 reg Wolstanton death reg 1894 age 0

John 1895 reg Wolstanton (age 6 1901 census)

Lilian 1898 reg Wolstanton  (age 4 1901 census)

William 1901 reg Wolstanton death reg 1901 age 0 (shown as 1 month old 1901 census)
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: J.R.Ellam on Thursday 06 April 23 07:18 BST (UK)
Hi

to be sure if you cannot find a baptism you will have to get the birth certificate.

John
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 08:59 BST (UK)
amondg,
Yes, looking at the ages it is likely Martha Ellen would be Ida's mother.
Thanks
Cheers.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: Biggles50 on Thursday 06 April 23 10:18 BST (UK)
maddys52,
Thank you for your reply.
There a no other siblings of the two shown in the census. As best i can tell the child (Ida Smart) ened up marrying an Eric Martin in 1935 in Staffordshire. I can't find a proper marriage certificate to verify her father.

A marriage certificate is not going to provide that information in a manner you can trust.

My Great Grandmother had her Grandfather listed as he Father on hers.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: Biggles50 on Thursday 06 April 23 10:18 BST (UK)
maddys52,
Thank you for your reply.
There a no other siblings of the two shown in the census. As best i can tell the child (Ida Smart) ened up marrying an Eric Martin in 1935 in Staffordshire. I can't find a proper marriage certificate to verify her father.

A marriage certificate is not going to provide that information in a manner you can trust.

My Great Grandmother had her Grandfather listed as her Father on hers.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: Maid of Kent on Thursday 06 April 23 12:59 BST (UK)
Name:   Ida H Smart
Registration Date:   1915
Quarter of the Year:   Jul-Aug-Sep
Registration Place:   Wolstanton, Staffordshire, England
Parishes for this Registration District:   View Ecclesiastical Parishes associated with this Registration District
Mother:   Smart
Volume:   6b
Page:   152
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: LizzieL on Thursday 06 April 23 13:17 BST (UK)
maddys52,
Thank you for your reply.
There a no other siblings of the two shown in the census. As best i can tell the child (Ida Smart) ened up marrying an Eric Martin in 1935 in Staffordshire. I can't find a proper marriage certificate to verify her father.

There is a likely Eric and Ida couple on 1939 register in Sussex - based on her date of birth range (from birth reg quarter) and a likely Eric Martin in 1921 living in the same area as Ida.
So that 1935 marriage looks very likely.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: brigidmac on Thursday 06 April 23 16:45 BST (UK)
Have you ruled out Lilian b 1898 as the possible mother .

I agree that the middle name HALL. Could be indicative of a. Birth father if it's not a family surname from grandparents.

There might be an affiliation order in county records giving father's name but you would have to pay for it .
Or a baptism might give a clue .



Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 18:18 BST (UK)
Plenty to consider here with all the records from the people above, again many thanks.
Great support as always from the RootsChat community.
I am leaning towards entering Ida as the daughter of Martha Ellen with a comment father possibly a Hall. I do think she is the Ida who married Eric Smart as shown in the 1939 registry.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: coombs on Thursday 06 April 23 18:39 BST (UK)
Yes, also add Lilian born 1898 as a possible mother, she may have had Ida at 17. Either Martha Ellen or Lillian. The only way to be sure would as said, buy the birth cert or find a baptism.
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: brigidmac on Thursday 06 April 23 19:23 BST (UK)
I think the best suggestion is to
add an extra sister to Martha and Lillian with first name " one of the sisters" as Ida's mother you can merge the mother to correct when you get the birth certificate or baptism with correct name

It will save confusing cousins with half siblings .
Title: Re: Grandchild Not Sure of Parent
Post by: RobinOz on Thursday 06 April 23 19:51 BST (UK)
Cheers brigidmac, will do.