RootsChat.Com

Old Photographs, Recognition, Handwriting Deciphering => Free Photo Restoration & Date Old Photographs => Topic started by: dubbleu_b on Monday 26 December 22 00:51 GMT (UK)

Title: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dubbleu_b on Monday 26 December 22 00:51 GMT (UK)
The attached photo was passed on to me with no identifying information other than the notation "Buckley Clan". I believe the photo is of my LIVINGSTONE ancestors who gathered in 1912 to celebrate the 80th birthday of CRAWFORD LIVINGSTONE, nee Spencer. The Livingstones came to Connecticut from Glasgow in 1873. A newspaper clipping confirms the event as taking place in September 1912 in Taftville, CT, and lists some family who attended from out of town.

I believe the elderly couple seated center are my g-g-g-grandparents JOHN LIVINGSTONE (1833-1917) and CRAWFORD SPENCER LIVINGSTONE (1832-1916) however I have no other photographs of them to be sure. I would like to confirm if possible by using clues from known photographs of other family members. Is this possible here? Can anyone help me confirm either way the identification of the following people in the photo? The second attached file includes photos of known family members.

I've listed their names, birth year, and my guess at who they might be in the "clan" photo:
Mary, b. 1854 (seated to the immediate right of the elderly woman?)
Margaret, b. 1858 (seated to the left of the elderly gentleman, dressed in black?)
David, b. 1869 (seated on the far left?)
Thomas, b. 1863 (holding the cornet?)
Alice, b. 1875 (seated far right?)
John, b. 1880 and Clara, b. 1882 (standing at the far right, immediately behind potential Alice?)
Sarah, b. 1877 (standing immediately behind the elderly woman?)
Grace, b. 1908 (small child standing far right, with potential Alice?)
Jesse, b. 1906 (girl seated on ground in front of elderly woman?)

Thank you for any assistance you can provide!
Wendy
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: John-76 on Monday 26 December 22 16:05 GMT (UK)
Can't do much about identifying, but here's a slight cleanup. A great looking family and all seem very happy!
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dubbleu_b on Monday 26 December 22 16:10 GMT (UK)
Great - thank you so much!
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: RJ137 on Monday 26 December 22 18:13 GMT (UK)
My Try - Clearer & lighter and Clearer B&W
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: RJ137 on Monday 26 December 22 18:13 GMT (UK)
My Try - Clearer with colour
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Gadget on Monday 26 December 22 20:28 GMT (UK)
Carol or Jim would know but I think the high collar style which most of the men are wearing is Edwardian - say 1908-10.
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Gadget on Monday 26 December 22 20:35 GMT (UK)
I've found a similar collar style which Jim has dated 1905 to 1912

https://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=449937.msg3120097#msg3120097

Gadget
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Lisa in California on Monday 26 December 22 23:17 GMT (UK)
Hi Wendy,

I didn’t open your second attachment, so I can’t help with identification.  But, I have a very similar photo of my ancestors, although there were only 19 people in my photo.  ;).  Mine was taken c1903.

I originally knew the identity of only two individuals. I eventually figured out that my gggrandfather (James, who was widowed) was in the centre of the photo. James’ adult children were sitting with their spouses, with the children sitting on the ground in front of their parents.  My grandfather was injured when he was young and I knew how many siblings he had, which made that family’s identification easy.  Once I realized the families were placed near each other, it wasn’t too long before I could identify everyone.  (It helped that James’ two unmarried daughters were sitting next to each other which helped me figure out that the married couples were sitting next to their spouses.)

If your folks used a similar seating arrangement, perhaps you might be able to look for family groups.  I hope this has helped.  Lisa
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Lisa in California on Monday 26 December 22 23:29 GMT (UK)
The man at the far right of the group possibly worked outdoors and wore a hat when doing so?  His forehead seems lighter than the rest of his face.

Do you know who played musical instruments?

Is it possible that the man seated near him was left-handed?  He’s holding his cigar in his left hand.
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dubbleu_b on Tuesday 27 December 22 01:24 GMT (UK)
Thank you. This is helpful.
There were a number of musicians in the family. Two sons David and Harry, were part of Buffalo Bill's Cowboy Band when they traveled through Europe 1990-1992. Both played the clarinet. Thomas played the cornet. A newspaper clipping about the birthday celebration says that father John "was at one time the leader of the Scotch drum corps of Taftville (Connecticut)."

Lisa - thank you for the idea of looking for family members clustered near each other. Makes sense!
Wendy
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Treetotal on Tuesday 27 December 22 12:22 GMT (UK)
The two and half inch men's collar was fashionable during 1908/1911
Carol
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: Gadget on Tuesday 27 December 22 13:02 GMT (UK)
The two and half inch men's collar was fashionable during 1908/1911
Carol

I'm glad you agree, Carol. I don't think the OP noticed my post about you and Jim  :-\

(Replies #5 and #6)


Add - that means that some of the dates don't match the people.
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dubbleu_b on Tuesday 27 December 22 19:32 GMT (UK)
Thank you for the help with dates. You are right that it means some things about the people don’t line up. Such a great photo and an even greater mystery!
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dobfarm on Wednesday 28 December 22 02:53 GMT (UK)
I've not much to add - only the ladies blouses from link below suggest +/- say 5 years of Edwardian times.

https://www.bing.com/search?q=edwardian+ladies+style+blouses&qs=NWU&pq=edwardian+ladies+style+blouses&sc=8-30&cvid=8BC74C017DD740FEAA074194FA10C402&FORM=QBRE&sp=1
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: shanreagh on Wednesday 28 December 22 06:11 GMT (UK)
Well I think the lady holding the child is the oldest and that the man to her right and the lady to her left are married to each other. 
Title: Re: LIVINGSTONE Family Photo - help with dating and identification
Post by: dubbleu_b on Wednesday 28 December 22 16:31 GMT (UK)
Well I think the lady holding the child is the oldest and that the man to her right and the lady to her left are married to each other. 
Interesting!

I've not much to add - only the ladies blouses from link below suggest +/- say 5 years of Edwardian times.
This is helpful - keeps the timeline broadly around the family gathering in 1912 [if they are the Livinsgstones].

https://www.bing.com/search?q=edwardian+ladies+style+blouses&qs=NWU&pq=edwardian+ladies+style+blouses&sc=8-30&cvid=8BC74C017DD740FEAA074194FA10C402&FORM=QBRE&sp=1