RootsChat.Com

General => The Common Room => Topic started by: peterpiper on Saturday 02 November 19 18:15 GMT (UK)

Title: Relationship ?
Post by: peterpiper on Saturday 02 November 19 18:15 GMT (UK)
Hiya folks, in a kerfuffle again, can't get my head round this
can someone solve this (probably simple) puzzle?
If A is the Grandson of B & D is the Grandson of C
With B & C being Sisters,
What is the relationship between A & D?
T.I.A.
Pete
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: Beavances on Saturday 02 November 19 18:18 GMT (UK)
Are they second cousins?
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: Gadget on Saturday 02 November 19 18:49 GMT (UK)
They share great grandparents (b and c's parents) so they are second cousins.

Gadget
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: peterpiper on Saturday 02 November 19 19:29 GMT (UK)
Thanks a lot, knew somebody on here would know,
just found me a 2nd Cousin I didn't know about
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: mckha489 on Saturday 02 November 19 19:37 GMT (UK)
Handy chart for future reference

Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: chris_49 on Sunday 03 November 19 13:30 GMT (UK)
It's a bit misleading, that one, isn't it? Going across, you get younger generations, but going downwards you find older ones - aunt/uncle, great aunt uncle etc. Yet the leftmost column lists child, grandchild etc when logically it should list parent, grandparent to fit in.

What some folk seem unaware of is that "once removed" can mean going a generation either way, and it's not specific. You could have two such cousins two generations apart (I do!) and a pair of cousins twice removed could be four generations apart!

My last surviving older first-cousin-once removed is first-cousin-twice-removed to my younger first-cousins-once removed.


Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: peterpiper on Sunday 03 November 19 15:48 GMT (UK)
Thanks for your replies,
Mckha489,
I have seen that chart before and thank you for showing it, but, being a thicky, can't get my head round it,  :-[ as my teachers used to say, "Must try harder"

chris,  Thanks mate, that makes my head spin, ???
I'm calling him a Second Cousin whether he likes it or not!
pete
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: chris_49 on Sunday 03 November 19 17:51 GMT (UK)
I like this one much better. Everything shown generationally.

http://www.devonfhs.org.uk/pdfs/tools/eichhorn-rlationship-chart.pdf

Thanks to Betty Eichorn, Devon FHS and Google.
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: Gadget on Sunday 03 November 19 18:04 GMT (UK)
That's the way I was taught to draw it way back when  :)
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: peterpiper on Tuesday 05 November 19 08:26 GMT (UK)
Chris 49,
"I like this one much better"
So do I, thanks,
pete


Gadget, When? ::)
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: Gadget on Tuesday 05 November 19 09:21 GMT (UK)


Gadget, When? ::)

When I was studying comparative kinship systems in my degree course in the 1960s.   ;D
Title: Re: Relationship ?
Post by: peterpiper on Tuesday 05 November 19 16:01 GMT (UK)
Gadget,   8)