RootsChat.Com

England (Counties as in 1851-1901) => Staffordshire => England => Staffordshire Lookup Requests => Topic started by: christopherworth on Monday 27 April 15 20:29 BST (UK)

Title: clara bagnall
Post by: christopherworth on Monday 27 April 15 20:29 BST (UK)
trying to find info on clara bagnall born lichfield 1858  Genes Reunited say she is on the 1861 and 1871 census in lichfield  i subscibe to findmypast and ancestry but she is not listed on their sites  i believe her father is george bagnall but would like to know what the census says  any help please

regards
chris
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: giggsycat on Monday 27 April 15 20:45 BST (UK)
Image on GR for 1861 & 1871 has parents as Edward and Ann.
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: whiteout7 on Monday 27 April 15 20:46 BST (UK)
Is this her on freecen? 1871

Father George Bagnall, Mother Lydia Bagnall

Piece: RG9/1930 Place: Burslem -Staffordshire Enumeration District: 24
Civil Parish: Burslem Ecclesiastical Parish: Christchurch
Folio: 104 Page: 9 Schedule: 49
Address: 33 Granville Place

George 46,   Earthenware Fireman, born Staffordshire - Hanley       
Lydia 41, born Lancashire - Preston
William 19, Earthenware Manufactring Clerk, born Staffordshire - Hanley       
Mary Jane 16, Earthenware Paintress, born Staffordshire - Hanley       
Edward J 14, Earthenware Gilder, born Staffordshire - Hanley       
Charlotte 11, Scholar, born Staffordshire - Hanley
Clara 4, Scholar, born    Staffordshire - Burslem       

What do you know about you family, is there any tradition of Pottery work?


Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: jan57 on Monday 27 April 15 20:56 BST (UK)
 1861 
Class: RG 9/1978/56 P 15
 living  in Queen St  Rugeley , 
Edward Bagnall 33  Iron Moulder 
Ann Bagnall  31
 Mary Ann Bagnall  7
 Edward Bagnall  6
 Frank Bagnall  3
 Clara Bagnall  2  born Rugeley  Staffordshire
 Lucy Bagnall  6/12


All the family  born Rugeley    which is  in Lichfield RD
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: jan57 on Monday 27 April 15 21:05 BST (UK)
  in 1871  The family  are   in the same  place  as in 1861,   Edward  is also  a Publican  now ,   and  the following  children  have  been  born  to the family.  Lucy   aged  6months in 1861   isn't with the  family  ,

 Albert Bagnall  8
 Ralph Bagnall  6
 Jane Bagnall  4
 George Bagnall  3

  This  is  possibly  Lucy 
Deaths Sep 1861   

Bagnall  Lucy     Lichfield  6b 190


Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: christopherworth on Monday 27 April 15 22:48 BST (UK)
thanks everyone for looking but no she is not from rugeley  we have her wedding cert which gives her father as george and she was possibly baptised in burton upon trent in 1861 giving her mother as sarah  just cannot work out why she cannot be found on either the 61 or 71 census  where was she its a mystery we cannot solve at the moment 

thanks
chris
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Monday 27 April 15 23:10 BST (UK)
What is George's occupation on the wedding certificate, and is he noted as deceased?

Also, any useful witnesses?

As you have identified her birth as Lichfield in 1858, then the certificate will give information as to her parents.

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Monday 27 April 15 23:23 BST (UK)
If this is the baptism record that you refer to, then is she illegitimate and has invented a father for the marriage certificate?

England Select Births and Christenings from 1538 to 1975
Clara Bagnall, baptised 27th February, 1861 at the Holy Trinity, Burton upon Trent
Mother Sarah Bagnall 
FHL 426513
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: Bookbox on Monday 27 April 15 23:46 BST (UK)
What place of birth is given for Clara in the census after her marriage?

If she is the one baptised in 1861 as above, maybe her mother married George BIRD in 1863?
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:N61P-R6Y

If so, maybe she was enumerated at Clara BIRD in 1871 in Burton?
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:KDD2-Q81

Maybe Clara 'borrowed' her stepfather George BIRD's forename when she married, to disguise her illegitimacy? In the above 1871 George BIRD's occupation was Maltster.

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Tuesday 28 April 15 07:07 BST (UK)
This might be Sarah Bagnall in 1851 (1841 father of this family is Samuel)
1851
Burton Upon Trent
Ann Bagnall   52  widow  washerwoman Marchonton Staffs
xxxxSarah Bagnall   17
John Bagnall   15
Mary Birch   36  Aunt
Martha Smith   15   dau
Class  HO107  Piece  2012  Folio  156   Page  5

Need Clara and Sarah together in 1861?
But think Sarah has married and is Cotton.
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Tuesday 28 April 15 07:19 BST (UK)
If she is the Clara born in Lichfield district in December quarter 1858, then as Rugeley is in the Lichfield district, this looks like her christening (from English christenings)

Clara
Baptism Date   5 December 1858 at Rugeley  Stafford 
Father  Edward Bagnall   Mother  Ann
FHL Film Number:   1040785  Reference ID:   2:RH9WSL

So have you identified the wrong Clara?

I thought genes took their census information from FindMyPast, so should show on there if you believe she is from Lichfield in 1861 and 1871
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 07:24 BST (UK)
The Burton on Trent baptism is available on FindMyPast -

Holy Trinity, Burton - 27 February 1861 - Clara - Sarah Bagnall - Burton - Servant

Additional information in the register for Clara in Rugeley is that Edward is an Iron Moulder, abode is Rugeley.

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: Bookbox on Tuesday 28 April 15 09:49 BST (UK)
Just to clarify, perhaps ...

The enquirer was wanting to check a census record for Clara Bagnall on GR. This Clara was found to be in Rugeley, with parents Edward (iron moulder) and Ann. The response was
Quote
no she is not from rugeley  we have her wedding cert which gives her father as george

So I think that rules out the daughter of Edward the iron moulder.

We are also told ...
Quote
and she was possibly baptised in burton upon trent in 1861 giving her mother as sarah  just cannot work out why she cannot be found on either the 61 or 71 census

This Clara was apparently illegitimate. If her mother Sarah had married or ‘regrouped’ after 1861, Clara could be under her stepfather’s surname in 1871. That might explain why she has not been found in 1871 as Clara Bagnall.

One possible marriage for her mother Sarah Bagnall (to George Bird) and a matching 1871 census showing a daughter Clara has been found (reply #8 above). There may be other possible marriages and matching 1871 censuses. But until we are told
(a)   Clara's place of birth in later censuses after her marriage, and
(b)   the occupation of her ‘father’ on the marriage certificate
... I think it will all be speculation. No doubt the enquirer will be back in due course. :)
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 09:59 BST (UK)
St Modwen - Burton on Trent - 9 September 1878

William Crump - 22 - bachelor, Whiting Clerk of Station Street.  Father:  William (dec) Clerk
Clara Bagnall - 20 - spinster, Domestic Servant of Station Street.  Father:  George (dec) Maltster

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: Bookbox on Tuesday 28 April 15 10:04 BST (UK)
Father:  George (dec) Maltster

Good find, BumbleB. Matches the 1871 found for George Bird  ;)
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 10:14 BST (UK)
St Modwen - 24 March 1863

George Bird - 28, bachelor, Maltster of Burton.  Father:  Charles, Labourer
Sarah Bagnall - 28, spinster of Burton.  Father:  Samuel, Shoemaker

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 10:22 BST (UK)
Possible 1841 - HO107/975/6 folio 16, page 25

? Yard, Burton on Trent - address either side is New Street.
Samuel Bagnall - 55 - Shoemaker
Ann - 40
William - 10
Sarah - 8
John - 6

The page is very faint, so not sure whether born in county or not
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 10:38 BST (UK)
1851 - HO107 2012 folio 156, page 5 - ?? Place, Burton (horrible hand-writing)  :o

Ann Bagnall - 52 - widow - washing woman born Marchington (I think)
Sarah - 17 - washing woman - born Burton
John - 13 - errand boy - born Burton
plus an aunt with daughter

Samuel Bagnall buried 8 January 1851, aged 68 - St Modwen
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: christopherworth on Tuesday 28 April 15 16:25 BST (UK)
many many thanks everyone  there is a person in canada who will now have to change all there tree around  they had the right family just the wrong people  i had seen the marrage to george bird and wondered if this was the one and that she may have been born out of wedlock  we had alot of people this morning studying the occupaation and came up with malter which i thought cannot be as it would have been maltster   now it all drops into place    will visit the library to see if i can find her on the 1861 census  she should be because the baptism is before the census +  there is no clara bagnall registered as born in burton upon trent 1855 to 1862  so not sure where she was born or what name she was registered as    she still poses problems to solve but i think we are getting closer

many thanks to everyone
regards
chris
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Tuesday 28 April 15 16:31 BST (UK)
Hi Chris:  prior to 1874 it was not compulsory to register a birth in England and Wales.  :'(
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: Bookbox on Tuesday 28 April 15 18:14 BST (UK)
It was compulsory actually, but the responsibility was the registrar's, not the parent's, so some births were missed. ;)
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: christopherworth on Tuesday 28 April 15 18:23 BST (UK)
having had a second look  as i said there is no record of a birth in the name clara bagnall around that date but there is a birth caroline cotton 1860  the baptism on 27th feb 1861 has 2 records in the same church caroline cotton george and sarah and clara bagnall sarah on the cencus later that year sarah cotton and caroline are living with ann bagnall who was sarahs mother  i cannot find any marrage between a sarah bagnall and a george cotton  later there is a wedding between sarah bagnall and a george bird and now they have a child named clara bird  there is no record of a clara bird b 1860ish  i have to think that caoline cotton clara bagnall and clara bird are all the same person  chrikey this hobby drives you mad but it keeps you active
regards
chris

Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Tuesday 28 April 15 18:35 BST (UK)
I wondered whether Caroline Cotton and Clara Bagnall were the same person.

But then I saw the 2 christenings, so how can they be the same??
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: Bookbox on Tuesday 28 April 15 19:05 BST (UK)
I believe there is a possible death for Caroline Cotton in 1862? Right now I am not somewhere where I can easily check, sorry ...
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: jan57 on Tuesday 28 April 15 19:49 BST (UK)

  From Free BMD

Births Sep 1860 

COTTON  Caroline    Burton  6b 310   


Deaths Mar 1862

COTTON  Caroline     Burton  6b 211
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: jan57 on Tuesday 28 April 15 20:09 BST (UK)
1861 census

 RG 9; Piece: 1965; Folio: 28; Page: 9

 Ann Bagnall  62  widow,  laundress   born Markington 
 Sarah Cotton  26  dau    married   dress maker   born  Burton
 John Eardley  28   boarder
 Henry Sutherns  25  boarder 
 Caroline Cotton  8/12   boarder     born Burton
 
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Wednesday 29 April 15 07:32 BST (UK)
Hi Chris:  prior to 1874 it was not compulsory to register a birth in England and Wales.  :'(

Not doing very well with my knowledge these days, am I?  :'(
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: christopherworth on Wednesday 29 April 15 16:39 BST (UK)
we at work discussed this today ourselves  we cannot believe the church would allow someone to baptise the same child with 2 names   i have no doubt sarah cotton is sarah bagnall  ann bagnall born marchington is her mother and the ages are correct   there is no record of a marrage between a bagnall and a cotton anywhere  the other problem is where is clara bagnall on the 1861 census,  she is nowhere to be found even if born out of wedlock she should be with her mother or grandparents or family  that said i think she has taken the name clara bird after sarahs marrage to george bird she is older on the 1871 census than the marrage date so her age fits  will keep looking   
regards
chris         
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: chempat on Wednesday 29 April 15 18:29 BST (UK)
Although there is no record of a Bagnall/Cotton marriage, a Sarah Bagnall gets married in Burton in June quarter 1859.

There are 5 names showing for 6b 415
Sarah Bagnall
Robert Blockley
Richard Jackson Eley
Elizabeth Mellow
Henry Orchead
so has a bride lost a groom?

Unfortunately cannot pair up with a George Cotton.

Added:
Just found that that marriage was in Swadlincote to Richard Jackson Eley, so scrap that idea.
Title: Re: clara bagnall
Post by: BumbleB on Thursday 30 April 15 07:58 BST (UK)
The transcription for the Swadlincote marriage says that Sarah is full age, father is Thomas Bagnall, agent.

There is also a Sarah Bagnall getting married in 1859 at Betley - Sarah Bagnall aged 19, father is John, Wheelwright.