RootsChat.Com
General => Ancestral Family Tree DNA Testing => Topic started by: Tricia_2 on Monday 31 March 14 03:33 BST (UK)
-
Hi :)
A number of my relatives have been kind enough to have DNA tests carried out for me - with some interesting results.
I wanted to get Y-DNA or mtDNA results for as many of my grandparents and great grandparents as possible. In order to get info for my maternal Welsh grandfather, I went to his brother's son.
The results came back: J-M241 / J2b2
I have traced this male line back to William Hampton who, according to the census, was born around 1813 in Worcester (or possibly in Worcestershire). Worcester is a town in central England and Hampton is a very English name, but J-M241 / J2b2 is rare in England.
How did this line get here? I don't know. Some have suggested Roman soldiers or other random travellers.
Is there anyone else out there with English J-M241 / J2b2 ancestry? I'd love to make contact.
-
Make sure you get your relative to join the haplogroup J2 project:
https://www.familytreedna.com/public/J2-M172/
For future reference there is a list of haplogroup projects in the ISOGG Wiki:
http://www.isogg.org/wiki/Y-DNA_haplogroup_projects
There is some information in Eupedia about the various haplogroups though the accuracy of the information is not guaranteed:
http://www.eupedia.com/genetics/
-
Hello DevonCruwys and thank you :)
Yes, we have joined the J2 project and some others that were relevant.
I did have a quick look through the Eupedia article and it is fascinating but I was wondering about how accurate it might be.
Since this Haplogroup is so rare in the UK, I think that it would be good to have a database of British J2 families :)
-
If it's of any interest I have a few J2s in my Devon DNA Project:
https://www.familytreedna.com/public/devon/default.aspx?section=yresults
Haplogroups aren't usually confined to country borders which is why the results are normally collated in international haplogroup projects.
There might be further insights when the Impact of the Diasporas project starts to publish its results:
http://www2.le.ac.uk/projects/impact-of-diasporas/archive-pages/Roots
The Eupedia website probably needs to be used with caution. They don't always provide sources for their data, but it's very difficult finding data on the frequencies of the various haplogroups in different countries and at least it gives you a rough idea.
-
... I have a few J2s in my Devon DNA Project ...
Hi. Sorry for the delay in replying. :)
It's interesting that you have a cluster of J2s in Devon.
It will become increasingly interesting to see the results as more people test.
-
So I'm in this grouping, but from my Dad's side, not my Mum's (who does have English ancestors).
However, doing my own research is seemed J2B2 (which is was defined as, before being regrouped into J-M241) was the group associated with the original Macedonian 4th Roman Legion - with clusters occurring where that legion had its bases.
Could that be the answer you're looking for - it seems to make the most sense, its that or maybe Jewish emigres somewhere back in time
-
Make sure you get your relative to join the haplogroup J2 project:
https://www.familytreedna.com/public/J2-M172/
For future reference there is a list of haplogroup projects in the ISOGG Wiki:
http://www.isogg.org/wiki/Y-DNA_haplogroup_projects
There is some information in Eupedia about the various haplogroups though the accuracy of the information is not guaranteed:
http://www.eupedia.com/genetics/
I don't seem to be allowed to join this group, even though I've been tested (through 23andme)
-
Vlad
The project is a FamilyTree one - have you transferred your DNA Raw data from 23&me across to FTDNA ?
Kim
-
... doing my own research is seemed J2B2 ... was the group associated with the original Macedonian 4th Roman Legion - with clusters occurring where that legion had its bases.
Could that be the answer you're looking for - it seems to make the most sense, its that or maybe Jewish emigres somewhere back in time
Hello Vlad. :)
Thank you for your thoughts and sorry not to have responded earlier. I only just found your posts.
I have been told, before, that this haplogroup might relate to Roman soldiers who came to Britain from the Balkans. This would certainly be very interesting, but I don't know how it could be proved.
Jewish emigres? Another interesting possibility. But, again, difficult to prove one way or the other.
There must be others with this DNA who are related to my Hamptons. DNA testing is still in its early stages. Hopefully, I shall discover closer connections in time.
Meanwhile, it's really good to 'meet' you, Vlad. Presumably we are very distant cousins :) How exciting!
-
Here is a way to prove your Roman Legioner's roots. Our family name Tsioungos and similar means "5" in Latin and has a clear meaning of Fifth Legion of Roman Empire, or "Macedonika Legion", because it was based at the North of Greece, Macedonia. Our family belongs to a Balkan's group of Roman Veterans - Vlach - Roman speaking minority in Greece, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Serbia, Romania, Albania and other neighboring countries. Read a story of Vlach, check DNA study of this group and you should find a good match, if your ancestors came with Roman Legions. For example, our Y-DNA, J2b2-CTS3617 (downstream of Z628). Look for J2b2 group at FamilitreeDNA.com Project on line and find your closest match. You'll see people from regions of ex-Roman Empire.
-
Hello Vlach. :)
Thank you for that.
I'll have a look and see what I can sort out :)
-
I agree...would someone start a board for J-M241 in England?
Hello. I have been trying to bust through my 4thGGF's brick wall for over 20 years! Joseph Jestings married in Nova Scotia in 1806. All census records and children's death and marriage records state Joseph's origin of birth as simply "England". Family rumor has it that generations ago the name was changed from something like "Justin". There are a small number of Justins in Sherborne, Dorset, England and a few close surrounding areas but no obvious connections seem to exist and I have found no one searching the name or ANY Jestings at all in England, Canada or the U.S. by the name of Jestings except the descendants that branch directly from my Joseph.
I have now discovered from testing my brother and father that our Y haplogroup/subclade is J-M241. Nothing comes up as a match. I have considered there may be illegitimacy, adoption, straight up name change for unknown reasons...you name it. Where would you turn next if it was your paternal line? My dream is to visit his birth village in "England". Thanks so much, April J-W
-
I was born and bred in the north of England and have never heard the surname before. This could possibly be due to the fact that historically Northern England tends to contain more Viking influenced names due to the fact that that part of England was ruled by Vikings for several centuries - and southern England had their own ancient tribal languages plus they had more Norman (French) influences.
However, I do know that "ing" at the end of a word usually means a tract of land and would suggest your surname derived from a farm owned by the "Jest" family. The "s" at the end of the surname could either be plural for more than one tract of land = ings - or in some areas of Britain an "s" at the end of a surname could mean "son of" = Wilkinson or Wilkins.
I was interested to see an online book describing the migration to Nova Scotia and presumably your early ancestors could have been fishermen; or farmhands,; forest workers or miners. If your migrant ancestor fished for a living it would suggest to me that he would have been born and bred near a river or the sea.
A National Archive search only brings up two "Jestings", one having the "Justin" alternative.
At one time, spelling was a bit haphazard and if you search for "Jestings" on www.familysearch.org
Then scroll down and click on the marriage years during the 1700s period, there are about 340 results for the same Jestings, or similar, surname in England. Searching for baptisms over the same period brings over 2000 similar names but very different spelling.
If you know your family followed a naming pattern and the given name you're searching for isn't on the family history website, it might be advantageous to contact the area archives and/or the local family history centre to see if they hold any unpublished church records. There are a couple of reasons for this:-When the Mormans (Church of Latter Day Saints) visited churches in the 1980s to film the books not all churches gave permission and some books were in private hands and eventually donated to the archives..
-
Rena,
Thank you for your reply and for putting thought and time into it. That is an interesting fact that I hadn't known regarding "ing", which is why message boards are often so useful. My Joseph (b.1776-77) had a good amount of offspring, one being a shoemaker. I haven't ever found anything on Joseph's original profession. He was only listed as a farmer, presumably because he was given a land grant in Nova Scotia by the crown. I have run across two other shoemakers related to the surname, one being a William Jestings of Sherborne b. 1717 and a Henry Cross who married an Elizabeth Jestings and would have been an uncle to some of the male Jestings in the town (IF) it wasn't a misspelling of the name. Many IFs of course. No one in Dorset or Somerset can come up with anything for me so I am scrambling for new ideas. I will investigate these new tidbits. Thanks so much!
April
-
ALJBW
Have you tested at FTDNA or have any of your tests been transferred there?
If you have an account with FTDNA you would be able to join the "England E I J Project" the Admin is English and runs the Project from England.
Primarily a Y Project but not exclusively so, it is a very active group and I am sure will be able to help you.
Kim
(Edit) You may find it as "England GB Groups"
-
I have just come back with a prediction of J2b2a M241 on my Y-DNA. My paternal surname Cossey is in and around Norfolk and Suffolk. To date I have traced to 1776.
-
Hello
My MtDNA is J2b2-m241. Our English and Scottish heritage goes back centuries both mother and father. I have only read about the Y-DNA online, but I think it would be similar to MtDNA (?) Maybe historically Roman, but currently we look more SW German to Irish, probably Celtic. I am trying to get some clarification after years but never has this gene testing been conclusive. Our heritage going back at least a Millennium is English and Southern Scottish, Northern Irish.
Nice to meet you all!
-
.... I have considered there may be illegitimacy, adoption, straight up name change for unknown reasons...you name it. ... April J-W
I am still trying to sort out my 'J-M241 / J2b2' line. Although the male line I know is named Hampton, that is not a name that I am seeing in the match list so I, too, am now considering illegitimacy, adoption, name change, etc.
Oh the joys of family history! :)
-
It's possible that there may be a little truth in the Legionary migration to Britain in the Roman era.
A recent dig in York found remains of a person who had J2 L228 Y-DNA establishing that J2 was present during the Roman period in Britain. It is likely that they spent their childhood in a dry, arid area, possibly N Africa or Egypt, before being buried in Yorkshire. In a modern context this DNA is found in the Caucasus, Balkans and Italy. The dig was at Driffield Terrace in York and this particular sample is referred to as 3DRIF-26. More info at https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fncomms10326/MediaObjects/41467_2016_BFncomms10326_MOESM417_ESM.pdf (https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fncomms10326/MediaObjects/41467_2016_BFncomms10326_MOESM417_ESM.pdf) read Supplementary Note 2 paragraph 1.3. The abstract is at https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms10326#MOESM417 (https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms10326#MOESM417)
I'm J2-L26 (J2a1) and my family seem to have been in the Shropshire/Denbighshire/Flintshire area as far as I can tell for several centuries, though there are very few (if any) Jones surnames on FTDNA with J2a1, the Montgomery surname is much more common. Probably an NPE or surname change I think.
-
A recent dig in York found remains of a person who had J2 L228 Y-DNA establishing that J2 was present during the Roman period in Britain.
Very interesting! Thank you very much for that information.
I'm J2-L26 (J2a1) and my family seem to have been in the Shropshire/Denbighshire/Flintshire area as far as I can tell for several centuries, though there are very few (if any) Jones surnames on FTDNA with J2a1, the Montgomery surname is much more common. Probably an NPE or surname change I think.
Do you think that this could be a Welsh patronymic thing?
This was suggested to me, regarding my late brother's Big Y-DNA matches.
-
@Tricia_2 Welsh Patronymic naming thing - yes, possible.
The Romans obviously travelled through France/Gaul on their way to Britain so it is likely there is traces of J2 DNA to be found in some of the Norman entourage that came here at the time of William I.
Imagine later Normans settling in the Welsh Marches townships such as Montgomery (named after Roger de Montgomery - founder of Shrewsbury Abbey). After a few years some may adopt the patronymic naming customs of Welsh locals, so a son of John (Ioan) becomes ap Ioan then later Jones.
Others may travel and be called by a locative name of their origin, so a lowly Henry who happens to come from Montgomery becomes known as Henry of Montgomery or Henry de Montgomery and finally Henry Montgomery - although there may be no direct relationship to Earl Roger or the Norman area of Montgomerie in France.
It's one area where DNA wins because the DNA stays constant and immutable, surnames can and do change - for that reason I am reasonably fluid if the DNA matches but the surname doesn't. However I don't get many matches in the UK with J2-L26.
The problem with patronymic names is that the ability to trace back the generations disappears after two generations unless you have a solid paperwork trail. You need a land owning farmer in the family with the appropriate title deeds and family history - something I lack.
Best of luck, pob lwc.