RootsChat.Com

Old Photographs, Recognition, Handwriting Deciphering => Free Photo Restoration & Date Old Photographs => Topic started by: brennan1 on Monday 11 October 10 21:21 BST (UK)

Title: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: brennan1 on Monday 11 October 10 21:21 BST (UK)
Hi all
Following the feedback and advice you gave with a previous attempt of mine, I decided to try and restore this one. Although it took many hours to complete I was pleased with the result. Am I getting there - slowly. A before and after image for anyone who would like to comment on, or offer advice as to how it could be further improved. Thanks to you all
Brennan1
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: treslade on Monday 11 October 10 22:23 BST (UK)
I can't give advice, but I have started to like see the before and after photos, and I am amazed at the talent that I see out there, well done to every one of you....and I had to say well done to you too, you are right to be please with your work, I wish I could be so clever.

Lee
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: billkent on Monday 11 October 10 22:50 BST (UK)
I wouldn't say you are getting there Brennan, I'd say you are definately already there...nice restore.

Bill.
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: brennan1 on Monday 11 October 10 23:01 BST (UK)
Thank you both Lee and Bill for your kind comments and support. Iam not at all clever, just trying to learn how to restore old photos of which I have many and have a great interest in old photos
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: Niksmum on Monday 11 October 10 23:19 BST (UK)
Well done That is really good. ;D
Heres another little hint...when there are pen marks it is sometimes easier to work in the blue channel ....

Keep up the good work

Irene
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: candleflame on Monday 11 October 10 23:21 BST (UK)
I can't comment on the pic as I have no expertise whatsoever but can you tell us the date of the pic as the clothes are quite distinctive and not something I've seen before Thanks
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: brennan1 on Monday 11 October 10 23:43 BST (UK)
Hi Irene,
Have yet to discover the blue channel but hopefully will do so in time as many of the photos I am attempting to restore have biro marks. I particularly like your restoration work a you manage to clean and restore photos without changing the facial features. This is the area I find the most difficult. Thank you for your hints
Regards Brennan1
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: brennan1 on Monday 11 October 10 23:49 BST (UK)
Hi Candleflame
The photowas taken about 1920 in Co. Wicklow Ireland. The scarf is fairly typical of what men wore particularly along that East coast of Ireland at this time.
Regards
Brennan1
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: candleflame on Monday 11 October 10 23:56 BST (UK)
Many thanks - it all adds to the knowledge base! I was intrigued by his jacket trim on the sleeves as well as the scarf.
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: Finley 1 on Tuesday 12 October 10 08:02 BST (UK)
Thats a great restore... good for you....

xin
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: ben32 on Tuesday 12 October 10 08:34 BST (UK)
absolutely amazing well done I for one cant even get a picture loaded, without trying to restore it, wish I had your talent
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: Ruskie on Tuesday 12 October 10 08:52 BST (UK)
Very very well done. But do you mind a little suggestion? Perhaps a little shading is needed under the lip down to the chin (as per the original photo) and the bottom left side of his mouth I think needs a little attention. Everything else is perfect!
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: oldhippy on Tuesday 12 October 10 08:52 BST (UK)
That's a very good effort. Keep up the good work.  :)
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: Treetotal on Tuesday 12 October 10 08:57 BST (UK)
Well done Brennan....You can certainly call yourself a "Restorer" now 8) I can add nothing but praise....It can only get better now...your speed will increase with regular practise.
Welcome to "Restorers Annonymous"....you have now aquired an addiction ;D ;D ;D
Well Done!!!
Carol
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: saddles on Tuesday 12 October 10 10:07 BST (UK)
Hi Brennan.........Keep up the practise and you will eventually achieve the level of success you want.

Like Carol said this photo restore/colouring is adictive so I hope you have plenty of time on your hands.

Carolyn  :)
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: DeniseJo on Tuesday 12 October 10 11:53 BST (UK)
I know nothing about photo restoring so forgive me if I get it wrong  :-\

The subject looks fantastic but for me the background is a little flat. Can you add some texture or shadows?
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: brennan1 on Tuesday 12 October 10 12:56 BST (UK)
Thank you all for the feedback. Yes it is very addictive and I have a lot to learn. I agree with your comment about the mouth needing improvement Ruskie but maintaing the facial features is the most difficult part of restoration for me. I can also see that the background as pointed out  by DeniseJo could be improved and hopefully I will learn how to change backgrounds eventually. OH there is so much to learn.
Thanks to all
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: mozza29 on Tuesday 12 October 10 15:29 BST (UK)
G'Day Brennan
Excellent work. Continuing pratice, (now that you'r hooked), will allow speedier completion of projects and I'm sure, given the results you have achieved already, many hours of personal satisfaction lie ahead.
Regards,
Morrie
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: mozza29 on Tuesday 12 October 10 15:35 BST (UK)
For Irene
Great tip re: Blue Channel, tried Brennan's before shot using that method and the underlying features and shading were much easier to correct,
Many Thanks.
Morrie
Title: Re: feedback on this 'restoration' if possible please
Post by: Niksmum on Tuesday 12 October 10 17:08 BST (UK)
Anytime  :D ........... Works for red splotches in the red channel too ;)

Irene